#BiharElections2020: Nitish is fighting anti-incumbency while party is grappling with the Question who after him?


In perhaps his last elections, Nitish is facing his toughest battle in Bihar. Sushashan Babu’s party Janata Dal (United) has launched the campaign ‘Nitish sabke hain’ at a time when its alliance partner Chirag Paswan’s Lok Janshakti Party (LJP) is putting up candidates against his party, ostensibly with the backing of the BJP.

Nitish has emerged as the undisputed leader of the alliance credited with taking Bihar to the path of development after jungle raj of Lalu Yadav. He is a perfect example of personification in Indian politics, Nitish is JD(U) and JDU is Nitish, much like Modi.

Over the years, he has crushed all competition within the party. He propped Sharad Yadav against George Fernandes and then dumped Sharad when he tried to emerge as a parallel power centre. Rashtriya Lok Samata Party’s Upendra Kushwaha left JD(U) in 2012 due to the dictatorial attitude of Nitish.

He appointed poll strategist Prashant Kishor as party’s Vice President after he crafted a strategy to defeat Modi. Prashant was touted as Kumar’s successor but the two fell out due to differences on CAA and other matters.

While Nitish is seeking a fourth term, question marks remain over the future of JD(U). Who after Nitish? The party is primarily built up of members of erstwhile Janata Dal in Bihar. With the weakening of the Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) many of its leaders have joined the JD(U). In fact its joked in the state that the membership of both parties is complementary.

A prime example is Shivanand Tiwari who has been close aide of Lalu as well as Nitish. He was in RJD (1997-2008), then JDU (20008-14) and now back to RJD (2014 – present).

There is no leader who commands similar clout as Nitish in JD(U). His close confidante RCP Singh, Lallan Singh and Basistha Narayan Singh lack charisma and state wide appeal.

The party faces the risk of disintegration post retirement of Nitish, many could go back to RJD or join BJP. Unless he appoints somebody as 2nd in command and oversees a transition in this tenure, assuming NDA wins. Kumar’s son Nishant has shown disinclination towards politics.

Over the past few elections the JD(U) has held hands with both sides, NDA as well as the MGB, this flip flop has branded Nitish as opportunist.

Aisa koi saga nahin jise Nitish ney thaga nahin” is a popular adage in the state.

JD(U) contested 2005 and 2010 Vidhan Sabha with BJP, 2014 Lok Sabha polls on a standalone basis, 2015 Vidhan Sabha with RJD and 2019 Lok Sabha with BJP.

Nitish by caste is a Kurmi. He has built a dedicated vote base of most backward castes and mahadalits, kurmis, koeris and a section of minorities. His standalone vote share is 16%. He has exhibited the ability to transfer this vote seamlessly without much leakage to its alliance partners BJP and RJD.

 2010 VS2014 LS2015 VS2019 LS
JDU Vote Share22.6%16.0%17.3%22.3%

Source: http://www.indiavotes.com

This strategy has provided him the flexibility to align with whoever he wishes to remain in chair. His core base has remained intact as he has devised specific schemes for mahadalits and MBCs. Kumar’s earlier posturing of keeping a distance from Modi also helped him to win some minority support.

JD(U) gets a leg up whenever it ties up with BJP, from upper caste and OBCs. It loses this vote while contesting alone. When contesting with RJD, while it maintains its vote share, the composition of its support changes, it gets more Muslim and Yadav votes.

JD(U)2014 LS2015 VS2019 LS
Upper Caste1%1%5%
Yadav3%5%2%
OBC7%5%10%
SC3%1%4%
Muslim1%5%1%
Others1%1%0%
Total16%17%22%

Source: Exit Polls, www.politicalbaaba.com

The above table shows that BJP is its natural ally, it is able to expand its reach while partnering with it. With RJD, the impact is neutral as he loses some OBC and SC support while gaining MY support. However, he has not been able to hold on to these vote blocks once JD(U) severs ties with these parties.

Despite his good work in the first two terms, Nitish hasn’t been able to expand his anchor voting segments. It is this fact which makes him dependent upon allies either BJP or RJD to remain in power.

However, this helps him to keep in check its overzealous ally BJP. If it arm twists Nitish too much, he can jump the ship.

This Article has been originally published here

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s